The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

9974 Federalist Dr, Fishers, IN 46037

About the community The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Your new home at The Reserve is a 34-acre neighborhood of choices. Our spacious, well-designed residences feature a variety of one and
two-bedroom apartments and two and three-bedroom cottages – including options for walk-in closets and dens. With rental or residency
fee plans available based on your choice of apartment or cottage, you’re sure to find the perfect home to suit your lifestyle and financial plan.

Conveniently located off I-69, The Reserve keeps you close to what you love. You’re minutes from shopping at Hamilton Town Center, the best in local dining and all the year-round leisure activities and entertainment opportunities you enjoy right in the heart of Fishers.

And if you ever need personalized support or more comprehensive health services, you’ll have preferred access to Hamilton Trace’s complete continuum of outstanding health care – assisted living, memory care, skilled nursing and rehabilitation. With a plan in place
for tomorrow, it’s even easier to enjoy today!

Family-first is our philosophy at Hamilton Trace, an approach that goes back to 1977, when CarDon & Associates was first established. As a member of the CarDon family of senior living communities, which extends throughout central and southern Indiana, Hamilton Trace...

Read More

Senior Living Options Offered

Assisted living
Independent living

Pricing for The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Total monthly costs depend on room type, select services, and the level of care needed.

Base fees by room type

1 Bedroom
Starting at
2 Bedrooms
Starting at

*Prices quoted are monthly rental charges and are provided by the communities themselves. Actual prices may differ due to one-time fees, timing and care services required. Speak with your Senior Living Advisor to learn more.

Amenities at The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Health Care Services

Diabetic care
Incontinence care
Ambulatory care
Medication management

Staffing & ancillary services

Hospice available on-site

Meals & Dining

Meals provided
Anytime dining
Guest meals
Professional chef

Room Amenities

Wheelchair accessible showers
Bath tubs
Respite or short term stays offered
Wi-fi/high-speed internet
Full kitchen
Ground floor units

Community Amenities

Memory care services

Memory care only community

Transporation & parking

Resident parking available
Complimentary transportation
Transportation at cost
Uncovered parking

Common areas

Outdoor common areas
Indoor common areas
Main street shops
Indoor atrium


Laundry service / drycleaning


Cats allowed
Dogs allowed

Recreational areas

Arts and crafts center
Billiards lounge
Fitness center
Game room

On-site dining options

Café or bistro
Private dining room


Devotional activities on-site
Devotional activities offsite
Art classes
Cooking classes

Reviews for The Reserve at Hamilton Trace


(17 reviews)

Write a Review



Care services




Meals & dining




Value for cost



Verified Review
A Place for Mom has verified the person writing the review and their connection to the community
1-17 of 17 reviews
August 20, 2021
Mark - Child of resident/client
My Father Now Has a New Home And They Have Made Him Feel at Home

It is an excellent place to consider. I would recommend you talk to the community about your loved one. The community is able to requests special requests from the residents such as second helpings.

June 2, 2021
Anonymous - Toured community

Very clean facility with skilled living but no availability right now. Will be a talking point with family

April 11, 2021
Anonymous - Toured community

This is a facility that had standard one bedroom, one bath, and setting area at approx 550 sq ft. The director there was impressive and focused on creating a culture of service and comfort. Their pricing was the lowest of the three that we looked at and the facility was new. The nursing lead had good questions for us and exhibited a spirit of partnership that we are looking for. This facility is a strong contender.

September 28, 2020
Anonymous - Resident/client
Great Place

We are very pleased with our place at the Reserve at Hamilton Trace. We received great help in locating this place from A Place For Mom.

August 23, 2020
Anonymous - Toured community

I adored the cottages. I think the use of space is perfect and the set up cute. The apt are alright. Not as new and as good of shape but I love the balacony.

January 20, 2020
Anonymous - Toured community

Could be interested in 3 bedroom cottage. [Name removed] and I visited The Reserve at Hamilton Trace and met with [name removed] on Fri. [date removed]. We were positively impressed and are definitely interested in this place. Unfortunately, they have no openings for cottages. We toured one of the 3 bedroom cottages (main floor with large finished basement) and it was way too big for our needs. Great location with LA Fitness across the street and only a few miles to the Fishers YMCA. There is no meal plan. Restaurant style dining appears reasonably priced and charges are added to monthly statement. I asked [name removed] about food cost and she said that for apartment dwellers, $400 per month is allocated for meals and rarely do those folks exceed the allotment.

April 24, 2019
Anonymous - Loved one of resident/client
Terrible Memory Care facility

If you are looking for a Memory Care facility for your loved one, do not put them here. The staff is not trained for Alzheimer’s patients who are mobile. They don’t smile, they don’t engage with patients, the don’t redirect or re-approach. They put patients in front of the nurses station to sit all day so that they can text or socialize. If your loved one gets agitated, they call an ambulance to take them to the ER. They have no communication within departments. You have to tell them over and over again your loved ones needs. Please don’t place your loved ones at this facility.

September 26, 2017
Anonymous - Toured community

Very nice accommodations and pleasant surroundings. Efficient organization and friendly staff.

May 23, 2017
Anonymous - Toured community

I am unable to rate this place yet, however our choice was based on the room, location and amenities. We decided she should enjoy the independent living as long as she can.

January 2, 2017
Anonymous - Toured community

Beautiful facility with every amenity. Staff and residents could not have been nicer. The perfect fit for my 91 year mother!

November 16, 2016
Anonymous - Loved one of resident/client
Verified Review
Accommodating Community

This has been a good transition for my mother with her move this community. She is doing quite well. I got most of my feedback from my sister who is close to her, I don't live in the same state. From what I heard so far everything is going well. We are comfortable with the care they are providing her with. There are plenty of activities for the residents. The management is very accommodating with my mother special needs. This is a good fit for her and her needs. Hopefully everything continues to go in a positive direction here at this community.

July 26, 2016
Anonymous - Toured community
Verified Review
Nice Looking Community

This is a lovely looking community. From what I saw everything looked very nice and well maintained. The staff was kind. They were informative and answered my questions. It is a nice community, but the location would not have work for the family.

July 14, 2016
Anonymous - Loved one of resident/client
Verified Review
It Has Been Great

This is a new facility and everything is sparkling new, very sharp. My sister is living here and she likes the food it absolutely tasty and cooked properly. My sister finds several interests in the activities available. It has been good for her.

June 22, 2016
Anonymous - Toured community

We really loved this place, however, the cost compared to almost comparable communities was higher. When we thought about the annual 4 - 5 % increase, it seemed out of our price range. Other than price, this community has everything going for it.

February 10, 2014
Loved one - Toured community
Verified Review
Very impressed by our tour

We toured this location when we were looking into care options for our loved one. This was a VERY nice looking community, and was our second choice. The rooms were a little smaller than what we were hoping for, and it was not located quite as conveniently for family members, so in the end we went with another community. But we were very impressed by what we saw here, and would recommend looking into it as an option.

September 23, 2013
Joyce J - Loved one of resident/client
Verified Review
Our Family's Experience at Hamilton Trace in Fishers

My mother has been a resident of Hamilton Trace since May 2013. It is her third care facility in less than one year as her health continues to decline. The staff has been excellent. We have learned a lot in a year and now know what to expect and appreciate in nursing care. We have monthly care meetings so there is good communication between our family and the staff. My mom is very happy at Hamilton Trace. It is very conveniently located for our family so someone drops by every day to see Mom. I would definitely recommend it. I know several people who also have loved ones at Hamilton Trace. That means a lot to me too.

September 4, 2013
A Place For Mom Customer - Toured community
Verified Review
I visited 2x but there are ...

I visited 2x but there are no assisted lvg rms open.The building was clean, the rehab rm was large,I think they could use more safe outdoor areas.

Neighborhood around The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

See what the neighborhood has to offer and what’s nearby:

Frequently Asked Questions about The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

The Reserve at Hamilton Trace offers 1 Bedroom and 2 Bedrooms. Learn more.

The Reserve at Hamilton Trace has received an average review rating of 4.3 based on 17 reviews. See all reviews.

Over 300,000 Families Helped

Please enter a valid full name.

Please enter a valid email address.

Please enter a valid phone number.

By clicking Get Started for FREE, you agree to our Terms of Use. You also consent that we, or our partner providers, may reach out to you using a system that can auto-dial; however, you do not need to consent to this to use our service. Our Privacy Policy describes information collection and use.

Similar Senior Communities Near Fishers, IN

1 / 3

Independence Village of Fishers South

9745 Olympia Dr, Fishers, IN 46037
(39 reviews)

Meadow Brook Senior Living

11011 Village Square Ln, Fishers, IN 46038
(50 reviews)

Heritage Woods of Noblesville

9600 E. 146th Street, Noblesville, IN 46060
(5 reviews)

Northridge Gracious Retirement Living

14532 Allisonville Road, Fishers, IN 46038
(60 reviews)

Allisonville Meadows Assisted Living

10410 Allisonville Road, Fishers, IN 46038
(70 reviews)

Independence Village of Fishers East

12950 Tablick St, Fishers, IN 46037
(22 reviews)

Bickford of Carmel

5829 116th Street East, Carmel, IN 46033
(17 reviews)

Wyndmoor of Castleton

8480 Craig St, Indianapolis, IN 46250
(71 reviews)

Crown Senior Living

7960 Shadeland Avenue N, Indianapolis, IN 46250
(6 reviews)

The features and amenities that are displayed on this page contain marketing information provided by the community. A Place for Mom has not confirmed the completeness of the provided information, and cannot guarantee its accuracy.

To conduct a complete investigation, seniors and their families should:

  • Tour any listed location to confirm the accuracy of the community description
  • Confirm that the community offers services that are required for the senior’s specific needs and budget
  • Check additional licensing and state audit information

If you become aware of any information that should be updated or noted, please contact A Place for Mom.

A Place for Mom uses the term “assisted living” to indicate that the community provides some level of assistance with daily living activities. It does not indicate that the facility meets official state requirements for level of care.

A Place for Mom is paid by our participating communities, therefore our service is offered at no charge to families. Copyright © 2021 A Place for Mom, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy & Terms. Do Not Sell My Personal Information.